In October 2026, the median Marco Island condo sold for $600,000, according to the Marco Island Area Association of REALTORS® monthly report. That was 20% less than in October 2025. On the mainland, the Naples Area Board of REALTORS® September 2026 report put the Collier County condo median, excluding Marco Island, at $400,000.
Island condos still sell for more than mainland condos, but the island median is falling. In our view, part of the explanation is a cost that never shows up in the asking price. A building's reserve study puts a long-term repair and reserve schedule in writing, and you can read it before you commit.
Condo documents to review
Before talking about price, start with the paperwork. These documents offer a look at a building's condition and finances:
- The association's most recent structural integrity reserve study, or SIRS
- The milestone inspection summary prepared by the inspector, if the building has had one
- The association's current financial statements and budget
Many buyers sign a contract first and skim these during the review period. On Marco Island they deserve a full read before you settle on a number. Together they offer a look at the building's condition, finances and expected expenses.
Milestone inspections on the island
Marco Island runs its own milestone inspection program through the City, and the City of Marco Island's milestone inspection page describes the program.
The City keeps those reports in permit records you can look up yourself. In the City of Marco Island permitting portal, choose Search, change the picklist from "All" to "Permit," open Advanced, select the permit type "Milestone Phase 1," and enter the building's street address. You can do this before you tour a unit. These rules are complex, and this post is general information rather than legal, tax or financial advice. Please confirm how they apply to a specific building and purchase with a Florida real estate attorney or another qualified professional.
How reserve studies fit into the picture
The inspection tells you the building's condition. The reserve study puts a long-term repair and reserve schedule in writing.
The study covers major structural and building systems. Section 718.112 of the Florida Statutes addresses condominium reserves.
What one building's study looks like
An example helps. South Seas North Condominium is a seven-story building constructed in 1978, with a reinforced concrete and block structure on piles and grade beams. Its structural integrity reserve study, prepared by W.J. Johnson & Associates and dated July 29, 2024, covers the period 2025 through 2034 and rates the building's SIRS elements in fair condition for a marine-area building of its age.
| Figure in the study | Amount |
|---|---|
| Opening SIRS reserve balance needed on Jan. 1, 2025 | $450,000 |
| SIRS expenses forecast for 2025 | $440,000 |
| Owner contribution, 2025 | $101,501 |
| Owner contribution, 2026 | $94,217 |
| SIRS expenditures forecast for 2026 | $17,510 |
The study also listed near-term items: the fire pump and one electrical breaker panel were at or near the end of their service lives, spalling concrete on the south elevation should be repaired within six months, some fire doors were not closing properly, and the building should be painted in 2025. The south-elevation repair was estimated at $20,000.
For a buyer, a study like this is a planning tool. It names the work, puts dates on it and attaches dollar figures. You can ask the association how the owner contribution appears in current dues and whether any work has been finished since the study was written.
A milestone report reads differently. Ville De Marco West, at 1200 to 1208 Edington Place, had a Phase 1 inspection dated September 9, 2024 covering five four-story buildings. The engineer found no substantial structural deterioration and no unsafe conditions, so no Phase 2 was recommended. The report still recommended timely work on the building envelope: isolated concrete repair, stucco, waterproofing, coatings and sealants. A clean Phase 1 report with recommended maintenance is a very different finding from a Phase 2 referral.
Reading these reports through the lens of construction is a large part of what Darren DiMare brings to our clients, drawing on more than 25 years in the building trades.
The October numbers, read with the paperwork in mind
These are the most recent island figures as of mid-November 2026:
| Measure | Marco Island, October 2026 | Change from October 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Median condo sale price | $600,000 | Down 20% |
| Median single-family sale price | $1.5 million | Down 16% |
| Active listings, all property types | 380 | Down 23% |
| Properties sold, all types | 48 | Down 13% |
| Average days on market, all types | 242 | Up 70% |
Inventory and sales fell together while the time to sell grew longer, and part of that longer average comes from vacant lots, which averaged 524 days on market. On the mainland, condos were selling faster. NABOR's September 2026 report for Collier County excluding Marco Island showed condos selling in 102 days, with 5.8 months of supply, 2,168 active listings, 291 closed sales and sellers receiving 94.0% of list price. Across the broader Naples-Immokalee-Marco Island metro area, Florida Realtors' September 2026 summary reported 342 condo and townhouse sales, up 8.2%, at a median of $432,500, up 4.2%.
Our reading is that on an island where so many buildings reached the 25-year mark together, buyers and sellers are now setting prices with each building's reserve schedule in view. Two units with similar views and floor plans can be worth different amounts because their buildings are at different points in that schedule. If you are comparing units, compare their documents too. If you are selling, having your association's SIRS, milestone summary and budget ready for buyers gives them a clear answer to their first question.
Quick answers
Where do I find a building's milestone report? Look it up in the City of Marco Island permitting portal under the permit type "Milestone Phase 1," then narrow the results by street address.
Where can I see what my current condo might sell for? You can request a home valuation, and our Marco Island neighborhood guide covers the island more broadly.
If you are weighing a Marco Island condo, or getting ready to sell one, The DiMare Group can go through the building's reserve study, milestone report and budget with you, so your offer or list price reflects what the building has planned. Contact us to start with the documents for the building you have in mind.